Free Updates

Let us tell you when new posts are added!

Email:

Navigation

Categories

Search

Archives

<December 2007>
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2526272829301
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
303112345

More Links


 Wednesday, December 05, 2007
A Group of One
Posted by Fred

 

Here we have a gold award medal inscribed “U. W. REGIMENTAL PRIZE DRILL” on an otherwise plain cross and wreath shaped medal. The brooch is inscribed with the name “Lee H. Huntley” which presented me with a research challenge. As it turned out Mr. Huntley was University of Wisconsin Class of 1908 and won this military ROTC (then known as the Corps of Cadets) award for drill in 1906. He graduated with a civil engineering degree and never spent day in the military or earned any other military medals. So here we have a single military medal which is also one man’s complete group.



12/5/2007 5:31:13 PM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)  #  Comments [0]
 Wednesday, November 28, 2007
Fake or Copy?
Posted by fred

 

Illustrated below is a US Navy Good Conduct Medal that I found in an estate. It is in mint condition and looks too good to be true. This medal is the rare first round medal version issued from 1880-1884. The size of this medal is an unusual 40mm in diameter which is an important red flag. Every other Navy Good Conduct I have seen is 32-33mm in size. My medal books don’t mention size when describing these medals so I posted this item on the US Militaria Forum site which is a site everyone reading this blog should visit. http://www.usmilitariaforum.com/forums/ . There I was quickly informed that the 40mm version is a “Collectors Copy” which got me to think that now would be a good time to discuss terminology. The terms Fake, Jewelers copy and collector copy as I see it should be defined as follows. Fake; an exact copy made to fool collectors with fraudulent intent. Collectors Copy; an inexact copy made for collectors to use as a space filler but with enough differences that knowledgable persons can tell the difference, in this case the wrong size. Jewelers Copy; these are usually exact copies made by authorized manufacturers and only sold as wearing or replacement copies which originally could only be sold to people who had earned the right to wear them. This is very common in the German issues especially in the higher orders and decorations. Jewelers copies are usually easy to spot due to lower material and workmanship quality.



11/28/2007 12:05:18 PM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)  #  Comments [0]
 Wednesday, November 21, 2007
Looks Like A Medal
Posted by fred

 

What appears to be a Canadian military medal really isn’t a medal at all . Starting at the top we have a bronze “CANADA” shoulder title pin signed “H.J. INGLS LIMITED”. Suspended from this shoulder title with a tartan-like plaid cloth ribbon is a cap badge of the 172nd Battalion of the Canadian Expeditionary Force known as the Rocky Mountain Rangers.

A few of my personal observations about this piece are that this is a First World War item and is not a medal of any kind. The ribbon, which is an indication of the unit’s Scottish heritage, hangs from the pin of the shoulder title thus making it impossible to wear this as a medal. The cap badge pendant is missing it’s pin and catch and is sewn to the ribbon using the remaining hinge as an anchor loop. My guess is that this assembly of items is a sweet heart, memorial or souvenir item. Any Canadian experts out there?



11/21/2007 11:32:59 PM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)  #  Comments [3]
 Tuesday, November 20, 2007
Greedy Wisconsin
Posted by fred

 

The Greedy State of Wisconsin and other states have been collecting sales tax on postage for several years now. I can understand that when paying for the shipment of a purchased item by mail the handling fees like any other service would be taxable but not the actual postage charged by the United States Post Office which is still part of the Federal Government. No state has the legal right to tax the Federal Government. If you think I am wrong in this view, ask yourself why is it that when you go to the post office and ship a parcel or buy some stamps the post office does not charge sales tax on these transactions. Granted it is easier to charge the sales tax on the entire amount rather than to separate the taxable handling charges from the actual postage but it still is wrong to do so. Since the amount of money per transaction or per individual is too small to justify a privately funded law suit no one has yet challenged this illegal taxation. Maybe it is time to consider a class action suit? Any lawyers out there? If so please feel free to chime in.



11/20/2007 11:41:13 AM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)  #  Comments [0]
 Wednesday, November 14, 2007
Launch and Christening Medals
Posted by fred

 

What’s better than a lot of broken glass and spilled champagne? As a military medal collector I would say adding another medal to my collection. It is traditional when launching a ship to smash a bottle of bubbly against it’s hull. Fortunately it is also a tradition to issue souvenir medals on such occasions. I don’t know much about this category of medals other than they seem to be rare. I’m also not sure if the terms “Launching” and “Christening” mean the same thing when it comes to ships. In any event I will illustrate the only two such medals I have come across in my years of medal collecting. The first one is for the launch of the USS Tennessee in 1919. The Tenn. earned 10 battle stars during WWII and was sold for scrap 1959, the same year that construction was started on the aircraft carrier USS Kitty Hawk which in turn will be decommissioned in 2008.



11/14/2007 12:40:29 AM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)  #  Comments [3]
 Wednesday, November 07, 2007
Three Different All The Same
Posted by fred

 

Here we have three different medals that are very different and yet also the same. After years of collecting I have come across about half a dozen of this type of military medal but will only use three in the scan. The medals are all very different at first glance from the basic radiant eagle design to the very unique and beautiful designs of the other two. All are different shapes. The medal on the ribbon is what I call a classic design of the First World War era. The second is a locally inspired design featuring a church which was a local landmark somewhere unknown to me. The third is a generic design found on many obverses of locally issued service medals from the First and Second World Wars.

Some similarities of the three medals are that all are bronze and intended to be worn suspended from a ribbon. All three were made circa 1919 and all three have blank reverses with only the makers identification on them. Most local service medal types have reverses with die struck designs and inscriptions stating the issuer and reason for the issue along with a space where the recipient’s name could be engraved. Few medals would have been issued with the intention of engraving the reverse locally. So why are these all the same? I believe that they are salesman’s samples. After WWI an army of salesmen canvassed the country trying to sell the idea of locally issued service medals and since there was no Federal WWI service medal until 1921 these salesmen were very successful. Thousands of different local types exist which is why most collectors limit their collections to only a few states and no one knows for sure how many medals would make up a complete set.



11/7/2007 1:25:34 AM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)  #  Comments [0]
 Wednesday, October 31, 2007
What Next?
Posted by fred

Back in the 1890’s through the early 1900’s being a member on the local National Guard Regiment was often like being the member of an exclusive club especially if the regiment was an elite unit from a wealthy area. Back in those days it was not uncommon for someone or some group to privately fund and establish a medal or an award just for a certain regiment. Such awards were usually for marksmanship or long service to the unit. These regimental awards were often very large and fancy and look much more impressive than one would expect. One such medal is the Illinois National Guard’s Second Regiment long service medal. After five years service a guardsman would get a large bronze medal hanging from a broach with the number 5 in a wreath. The reverse of the medal was inscribed with the recipient’s rank, name and the date of the award. Then in another three years a silver eight year pin-back bar broach was added and the pin was removed from the five year broach. Four years later, you guessed it, a twelve year gold bar was added. If things went really well for our guardsman in another three years he would get a fifteen year eagle with a ruby to perch on top of his twelve year bar. The medal illustrated here is the only 15 year version I have ever run across and would have been awarded the fifteen year distinction in 1907. So what if the same man stayed on beyond fifteen years? I would guess that this medal was closed to further add-ons and that in another five years a special twenty year medal would have been prepared for this senior guardsman.



10/31/2007 9:12:16 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [0]
 Wednesday, October 24, 2007
George Rogers Clark Medal
Posted by fred

 George Rogers Clark Medal

Starting at the beginning George Rogers Clark (1752-1818) was born in Charlottesville, Virginia Nov. 19, 1752.He was the older brother of William Clark who was the Clark in the famous Lewis and Clark expedition. His military service began as a scout in Lord Dunmore’s war of 1774. Clark then settled in Kentucky and organized the militia defense against the hostile Indian allies of the British during the revolutionary war. About this time Clark was promoted to Lt.-Colonel and made Commander of the Kentucky frontier militia. In 1778 Clark led a 175 man expedition down the Ohio and into Illinois where on July 4 they captured Kaskaskia and then Cahokia and Vincennes in August of the same year. Vincennes had to be recaptured Feb. 25, 1779. Now as a Brigadier General Clark led a successful expedition against the Shawnee and repelled a British and Indian attack on the then Spanish settlement of St. Louis in 1780. In Jan. of 1781 he assisted in repelling attacks led by Benedict Arnold. From 1783-1786 Clark was the US Indian Commissioner and led an expedition against the Wabash tribes. During the 1790’s Clark was involved in several failed French and Spanish colonization schemes trying to better himself financially and then retired to Louisville, Kentucky until his death Feb. 13, 1818.

The medal, 20 x 34.4mm is bronze and in the shape of a stone arrow head with Clark's portrait on the obverse facing to the left. The inscription “KY GEORGE ROGERS CLARK TRACE” is above and below the portrait. (What is meant by the word “Trace” is unknown to me.) The reverse is blank except for the makers name “Medal Arts Co. Roch. N. Y. " The ribbon is faded and discolored but the original colors were probably blue and white. My guess is that this medal was made in the 1920's and is rarely seen on that large internet auction site.



10/24/2007 12:50:31 AM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [2]
 Wednesday, October 17, 2007
Nature Abhors A Vacuum
Posted by fred

Nature abhors a vacuum and so does human nature. After the First World War a defeated Germany found itself in a vacuum. The imperial and royal governments had fallen. The weak Weimar Republican government had so completely disavowed war and the military that it refused to issue any medals for WWI service. Millions of veterans who served honorably and suffered so many hardships (as did the veterans on all sides) came home to a government that wanted to forget the last 4 ¼ years. To fill this medallic void numerous German veteran and patriotic groups issued a flood of WWI service awards. Even some former allied countries like Austria, Bulgaria and Hungary issued medals. The medals were sold to anyone who felt that they were entitled to wear a particular medal. As a result medal groups can be found with many interesting combinations of medals which often are totally unverifiable. The field is vast and not yet completely cataloged. One could spend a life time just collecting these unofficial awards. Illustrated below are just four of the better looking examples, one from each of the former kingdoms of the Germany Empire: Bavaria, Prussia, Saxony and Wuerttemberg. Take a close look and see if you can figure out which is which.



10/17/2007 12:42:23 AM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [2]
 Wednesday, October 10, 2007
USS Wisconsin
Posted by fred

As far as collecting militaria goes I have never been a naval minded person; maybe because I never liked naval uniforms. So when I stumbled across this USS Wisconsin crew member lapel button I was forced to think naval. First the Wisconsin was launched in Dec. of 1943 and served well through the remainder of the Second World War and then during the Korean War‘s so called “Police Action.” In 1986 the ship was reactivated and modernized, served during the war with Iraq and was again mothballed to save money. Now the ship is again considered obsolete and it is doubtful that it will ever see action again. Ships of the navy have huge crews, the Wisconsin for example had a crew of almost 2000. Since most sailors in uniform look pretty much alike and often times more than one navy ship will be in any one port at the same time it could get confusing and time consuming for sentries to have to check the papers of each sailor before letting them board a ship especially when large numbers of them show up at once. The crew identification button sounds like a good idea to me. The only thing I don’t know is if my conjecture about this button is correct.



10/10/2007 2:52:34 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [0]
 Wednesday, October 03, 2007
Welcome Home
Posted by fred

 

The lapel button illustrated below is an error. The 83rd was a regular infantry unit

 which saw a lot of action in WWII suffering 3,637 battle deaths. It was not an

 Air Borne unit. So was the intention of the issuers to celebrate the 83rd’s return

or were they really thinking of the 82nd Air Borne. I’m sure the guys coming

home were too happy to let this screw up bother them but it makes for interesting

collecting.



10/3/2007 12:28:32 AM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [0]
 Saturday, September 29, 2007
Where have all the medals gone?
Posted by fred

Was on vacation last week and spent the time touring the antique malls of Northern Wisconsin and Eastern Minnesota which got me to thinking.  What follows are some rambling thoughts and observations.

As some of you may know I have been a collector of military medals since the

 mid 1960’s. I started out by buying medals at coin shows and from ads in coin

 publications. From there I got on dealer lists and started going to gun shows and

flea markets. Then in the 1970’s antique malls started springing up like

mushrooms and became my happy hunting grounds. Over the same time period it

seems that the number of military medals collectors has increased faster than the

rabbit population. Anyhow over the last few years I have noticed a steady

decline of available material in the malls and that what I am finding in the malls is

common, misattributed and or grossly over priced. Best example of this was in

an antique mall on highway 29 in Wisconsin where some very nice merchant

 trying to be helpful offered me a 9th infantry distinctive insignia as a fireman’s

 badge for the bargain price of only $50!! At another mall I saw a large framed

photo of an Austrian soldier from the early 1900’s with a tag listing the man’s

 name and calling him an Australian soldier for only $750. The frame was fancy

and the photo was nice but I still think the price was excessively optimistic. Then

there are the full crocks of BS out there. We as coin collectors have all seen

 the large cast copies of coins from Indian cents on up being sold for $2-3. Well

I saw a Standing Liberty quarter version in a Minnesota antique mall labeled as a

“Political Token” and priced at only $225. The fact that the dealer had several of

these RARE items didn’t seem to cause any doubt as to their value. Well at least

 he had his items clearly priced which often is not the case in many display cases

that I see in antique malls. I don’t know how these mall venders think they can

 sell anything that doesn’t have the price clearly visable to prospective buyers

 through the locked glass case. In large antique malls like the big ones in

Stillwater, Minn. I will not bother to get the staff to open a case for me simply for

a price check unless the item in question has the potential to be really rare.

 Speaking of Stillwater, Minn, this was one of my favorite antiquing destinations.

 There used to be so many malls and shops there it would take 2-3days to go

through them all but things are changing there too. Over the last few years there

 has been a condo building boom in Stillwater which destroyed many of the

 smaller antique shops on Main street. Many of these condos have yet to be sold

due to the down turn in the real estate market. Of the remaining stores many are

vacant now and for sale due to the skyrocketing real estate taxes which have

 increased yearly I am told. One antique book dealer told me he decided to sell

 this year when his taxes jumped 160%. I asked him when the last tax hike was,

 thinking this one may have been long over due, “last year” he said and that was

 60% if my memory is correct. If the economy doesn’t get you the government

 will! I hate to think that in the not too distant future the only place for collectors

 to buy and sell will be the internet. Well I have rambled long enough, if you have

any thoughts to share please do so.



9/29/2007 5:10:15 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)  #  Comments [0]