Free Updates

Let us tell you when new posts are added!

Email:

Navigation

Categories

Search

Archives

<November 2008>
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2627282930311
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30123456

More Links


 Friday, November 30, 2007
Is that foul-looking fowl really an eagle?
Posted by bob

Next year, when the state quarter program ends, the plan is for the quarter’s reverse to revert to showing an eagle, as it had prior to 1999. That’s not a bad thing. Though Benjamin Franklin argued for adopcm1031b.jpgting the turkey as the national bird (he thought the bald eagle was of “bad moral cm1131b.jpgcharacter”), an eagle has appeared on most U.S. silver and gold coins since the opening of the U.S. Mint in 1792.

This national symbol, however, has not always been shown at its best—at least not according to would-be art critics of the past. Take for example the scrawny creature on the back of the half disme in 1792 or the underfed bird on the 1794 dollar. Both of these birds ruffled some feathers.

But they were not alone.
cm1018561.jpg
When the Flying Eagle cent was released, in the 1850s, some termed it the “buzzard” cent.
1248.jpg
In the 1920s, the eagle on the back of the Standing Liberty quarter was shamed in a press dispatch out of New York that complained that it faced the wrong way, which signified cowardice. The fact that it was winging across the coin didn't help. That, according to the dispatch, symbolized speed, meaning it was: “A coward and a fast running one.”

Adolpcm0322b.jpgh Weinman’s eagle on the half dollar, released in 1916, also raised a flap. An ornithologist claimed Weinman had made the bird look like it was “wearing o1922-Srcm0924.jpgveralls and marching through tar.”

A Chicago newspaper thought the eagle on the back of the Peace dollar looked like a tom turkey. (Franklin would have been proud.)

Some of the criticisms were fair. Others were not.

If I had to criticize one eagle on a U.S. coin, my choice would be the bizarre-looking creature on the 1936 Bridgeport commemorative half dollar. It’s definitely modernistic in design. But it hardly looks like an eagle.cm0711btest.jpg
upsidedown2.jpg
For some reason, it has always reminded me of a whale with its mouth wide open. Of course, you have to ignore the legs. Commemorative authority Anthony Swiatek has noted that, if you turn the coin upside down, the eagle looks like a shark. Again, the legs are a problem.

But let's talk turkey (or in this case, whale- or shark-like eagle). Either way, that’s one foul fowl.














11/30/2007 3:27:24 PM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)  #  Comments [0]
 Tuesday, November 27, 2007
Ever see 1 million silver dollars?
Posted by bob

Have you ever seen 1 million silver dollars?

It was long before I began collecting coins, but the tale of the Million Silver Dollar Exhibit at the 1962 Seattle World's Fair is fascinating nonetheless.

Three Washington numismatists were behind bringing the coins to the fair. The three, who had formed Northwest Historic Medals Inc. to strike a series of medals commemorating the great water-power dams in the Pacific Northwest, had approached the Century 2million.jpg1 committee, organizers of the fair, with plans for producing a set of medals to promote each of the seven planned exhibits at the fair. Along with an already-authorized U.S. Mint medal, Northwest said the eight-medal set would make a great souvenir of the fair.

To cinch the deal, they had one other idea that really got the committee enthused. “If numismatics is going to take part in this Fair, the three reasoned, it ought to take part in a big way. The more money the better,” as the September 1962 issue of Coins magazine explained.

“Almost everyone dreams and talks about a million dollars, but how many people have ever seen that amount of cash in one place at one time?

"Why not have a display featuring one million silver dollars? Here, all in one, would be the most money the visitors would ever see, coupled with an intriguing chapter of American history."

Having received encouragement from the committee, the next step was to find the 1 million silver dollars.

Although the silver dollar is today well liked by collectors, high mintages and a lack of use led to bags upon bags remaining in government vaults through much of the 20th century. So getting the coins was a financial and logistical concern, but not impossible. Another concern was: If they could win approval to obtain the coins from the government, where would they store them?

The problem was solved when Northwest’s president saw an ad for steel buildings in a trade magazine and decided to approach the advertiser, Behlen Manufacturing Co., Columbus, Neb., with a promotional idea.

Northwest proposed that Behlen construct a building to be placed at the fair to house the silver dollars. “The proposal, startling at first, sounded like a winner, and, after discussing it with other company executives, Behlen went to work,” Coins reported.

“Within weeks, the idea had been cleared all the way to Miss Eva Adams, director of the Mint…and plans made to transport the coins from Philadelphia to Seattle.” The coins would earn interest for the government while they were on loan to the exhibit.

While details were being worked out on shipping the coins, and construction began on the building in which to hold them, Northwest went about designing and striking the medals, including a new one honoring the Million Silver Dollars Exhibit.

The fair’s opening date was April 21, 1962, and Behlen worked quickly to construct the corrugated steel building, while two Chevrolet diesels were employed to carry 500,000 each of the silver dollars, still in mint-sealed bags, from the Philadelphia Mint to the fair.

“Pinkerton guards rode with the trucks, state troopers and local police drove guard as the semis roared westward, following the trail cut by free-spending miners and frontiersmen who’d rather get rid of their bulky silver dollars than lug them around in their pockets,” explained Coins.

Once at the fair, 800,000 of the coins (Morgan dollars apparently, as the Coins' article notes they were in bags sealed between 1910 and 1915) were stacked in the center of a Behlen corn crib enclosed in glass. “Then over and around the bags were poured a clinking cascade of 200,000 Peace dollars: 1,000,000 silver dollars, just for looks, just sitting there gathering 167 dollars a day in interest,” Coins wrote.

“But that’s not the only ktruck2.jpgind of interest the $1,000,000 display gathers. Each day the Fair is open this summer, more than 25,000 visitors pass through the steel building and gaze wide-eyed at the most money they’ve ever seen. On busy days 40,000 pairs of eyes repeat the performance.”

In June, when the 1 millionth fair visitor walked into the exhibit, a California resident, she was presented with 100 of the silver dollars from exhibit.

Interestingly, if you wanted, besides the nine-medal set, housed in blue Whitman bookshelf album, you could also purchase silver dollars from the exhibit.

As Northwest's president explained to Coins: “‘They’re for sale. Anyone interested in picking up a Mint-sealed bag of dollars minted prior to 1910 can put down $200 and pay the balance by the 5th of October. We’ll deliver by the 22nd.’”

An advertisement on the back inside cover of the November 1962 issue of Coins offered individual silver dollars from the exhibit, “mounted in an attractive World’s Fair holder,” for $1.95 postpaid. The limit on the bags was five bags per person (at $1,500 per bag of 1,000 silver dollars), to be shipped after the exhibit closed.

Shown here are the coins in the corn crib, along with the trucks that brought them to Seattle, parked in front of the exhibit building at the Seattle World's Fair.





11/27/2007 12:44:25 PM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)  #  Comments [1]
 Thursday, November 15, 2007
Worn to perfection
Posted by bob

Today everyone wants ultra-grade coins. Many of those who buy directly from the U.S. Mint quickly send off these coins to one of the third-party grading services to see if they can score a coin in a high mint state or high proof grade and then sell it for a fortune.

What ever happened to the good old days of collecting, when a coin's grade wasn't always the most important factor in whether or not it was collectible?
bad.jpg
I remember when I started collecting, I liked to carry around an Eisenhower dollar with just one goal—to see how worn down I could get it. I eventually had it well worn, but then misplaced it.

It was, however, not as worn as the Eisenhower dollar in this photo. It's obvious this collector was going for the worst of the worst. His hang-up on grade was in finding the worst specimen of various types of large U.S. dollar coins. And it looks to me like he did an admirable job.

In the top row is an 1803 Draped Bust dollar, next to it is broken apart 1850 Seated Liberty dollar, followed by an 1877 Trade dollar. In the bottom row are a Morgan dollar, Peace dollar and an Eisenhower dollar. The dates on these are all too worn to read.

No need to rush these bad boys in for slabbing. Borrowing a grading term from the 1800s I used in an earlier posting, these start out at "wretchedly poor" at best.




11/15/2007 4:55:45 PM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)  #  Comments [0]
 Thursday, November 08, 2007
But I could have had a Dr. Steinmetz coin
Posted by bob

It was once suggested that I write a book on coinage measures that were proposed but didn't pass into law. It would have been a mammoth and likely tedious process and probably of dubious worth. However, it's sometimes fun to look back at what might have been, what could have been, and what maybe should have been.

Collectors today are not unknown for their grousing about there being too many coins being offered by the U.S. Mint, and that you'd have to be rich to keep up.

A look back at the mid-1930s, during the heyday of the classic commemorative coinage series, suggests that today's collector is not alone in the feeling of being overtaxed.

In 1936, for instance, collectors were offered the following commemorative half dollars, many of which were coined only in that year and others that were continuing series:

Albany, New York, Charter; Arkansas Centennial; Battle of Gettysburg; Bridgeport, Connecticut, Centennial; California-Pacific International Exposition; Cincinnati Music Center; Cleveland Great Lakes Exposition Centennial;  Columbia, South Carolina, Sesquicentennial; Delaware Tercentenary; Elgin, Illinois, Centennial; Long Island Tercentenary; Lynchburg, Virginia, Sesquicentennial; Norfolk, Virginia, Bicentennial; Oregon Trail Memorial; Providence, Rhode Island Tercentenary; Robinson-Arkansas Centennial; San Diego Pacific Expo; San Francisco Oakland Bay Bridge Opening; Texas Centennial; Wisconsin Centennial; and York County, Maine, Tercentenary.

But that's only half of the story. A look through issues of The Numismatist for 1936 gives a frightening view of what might have happened in the future if all of the laws submitted for commemorative coins had been approved. Those that didn't make it included:

  • A bill for a half dollar honoring the 50th anniversary of the founding of borough of Wilkinsburg, Pennsylvania.
  • A bill for a half dollar for the 150th anniversary of the adoption of the Constitution of United States.
  • A bill for a half dollar to commemorate the 400th anniversary of the journey and explorations of Francisco Vasquez de Coronado.
  • A bill for a half dollar for the founding of the International Peace Garden at the international boundary line between the United States and Canada, in the Turtle Mountains of North Dakota and Manitoba.
  • A bill for a half dollar for the 160th anniversary of the arrival of General George Washington and the Continental Army at Morristown, New Jersey, after their inspiring victories at Trenton and Princeton, and the establishment of cantonments in Morristown for the duration of the war.
  • A bill for a half dollar for the World's Fair to be held in New York City in 1939 in commemoration of the 150th anniversary of the inauguration of the first President of the United States of America and of the establishment of the Federal Government in the city of New York.
  • A bill for a half dollar in commemoration of the memory of the late Dr. Charles P. Steinmetz.
  • A bill for a half dollar for the 300th anniversary of the founding of Hartford, Connecticut.
  • A bill for a half dollar for 100th anniversary  of admission of Michigan into the Union.
Two other measures—one for a Tri-State (Texas, Louisiana, and Arkansas) half dollar and another for a half dollar for 100th anniversary of the arrival of Marcus and Narcissa Whitman in the Walla Walla, Washington area, and founding of the Waiilatpu Mission—were changed to medals instead of coins.


11/8/2007 5:37:54 PM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)  #  Comments [0]